Showing posts with label EU. Show all posts
Showing posts with label EU. Show all posts

Friday, 9 December 2011

Two Speed Europe?

We've all woken up this morning to the breathlessly conveyed news that the European political elites have staged an all nighter with the result that most of them have agreed to sign up to a new Treaty to deal with the crisis in the Eurozone. But not Britain.

Predictably, the initial coverage in our domestic media is very much focused on the 'Europsceptic v Europhile' axis. Some idiot Tory backbencher seemed to claim we had left the EU on the the Today programme. This is plainly not true, but we do now formally have the much heralded 'two speed Europe'' coalescing before our eyes. 

Or we do if this new Treaty actually materialises and gets anywhere close to being implemented. This seems rather more important - and rather more of an open question - than the initial UK coverage is allowing for.

To recap: several European nations are, in effect, broke or teetering on the edge of insolvency (this is sometimes dressed up as 'experiencing severe liquidity problems'). For some of them this is primarily  a result of decisions to support failing banks, for others it is perhaps more about failing to establish any kind of effective tax regime.  They mainly owe the money to French and German banks - including, Peston says, increasing quantities to the Bundesbank itself.  This money is denominated in Euros. Let's put it politely: there are very reasonable grounds for suspecting these debts will not be paid or even serviced by the payment of interest. This might yet break the Euro and cause a disorderly return to national currencies - an event that could plunge the world into depression.

So the new Treaty is about imposing a unified fiscal regime on all the signatures subject to qualified majority voting. In other words, a very, very significant slice of national economic policy will be subject to ultimate control by 'Brussels' (understood as a Franco-German hegemony), not national parliaments. Since everyone pays at least lip service to the idea that the way out of the problem is growth ( because debts are easier to pay off out of a growing pot) the question becomes what policies should be pursued to achieve growth - and Brussels will get the final say on what those policies should be. & they really won't include deficit spending on Keynesian stimulus lines:

" Eurozone states' budgets should be balanced or in surplus; this principle will be deemed respected if, as a rule, the annual structural deficit does not exceed 0.5% of gross domestic product.
• Such a rule will also be introduced in eurozone member states' own national legal systems; they must report national debt issuance plans in advance.
• As soon as a eurozone member state is in breach of the 3% deficit ceiling, there will be automatic consequences, including possible sanctions, unless a qualified majority of eurozone states is opposed."
 In short, this is a recipe for a Treaty which cuts living standards and the social wage across Europe by over-riding democratic mechanisms. Now Cameron et al have no objection to that per se - how could they, given their domestic policy ? - their beef is with the idea that the City of London might end up being regulated by Brussels rather than (un)regulated by Whitehall or the Bank of England. & it is the City of London and other bourses which have done so much to create this web of unsupportable credit in the first place. So the likes of Richard Murphy find themselves 'strangely conflicted' between a passed up opportunity to control the banksters and sighing with relief at escaping diktat by bureaucrat.

But let's leave that aside for a moment. Let's ask another question - are the plans for this new Treaty actually plausible? Will the peoples of Europe accept them? Or will various European governments, under pressure from their electorates,  find themselves increasingly looking for 'workarounds' just as they did over Maastricht and Lisbon? The 'optics' of this proposed new Treaty are all wrong - its an elite deal stitched up without reference to anyone. It's going to be be terribly politically fragile even if it does manage to stagger through to an actual signing.

The real two speed Europe we should be talking about is not Britain v (most of) The Rest - its about how the politics and the economics of this crisis are working at such different paces from each other, and have to work at such different paces or have governments face the loss of democratic legitimacy. This new Treaty seems an attempt to subsume the political  dynamic to the economic one, defined purely as the economics of financial markets.

The gut feeling of this non economist is that it ain't going to work. 

Addendum

Mason observes:
...by enshrining in national and international law the need for balanced budgets and near-zero structural deficits, the eurozone has outlawed expansionary fiscal policy.

It has done what the US Republicans would like to do - and if you think about it, it has made what Gordon Brown did, and what Barack Obama (and indeed Wen Jia-bao) is doing illegal.

What's more no one yet even certain if it will convince the markets. 


Tuesday, 13 July 2010

Nationalism and Globalisation: Two Snapshots in Time

Mason's blagged his way into a party:

Another obvious social and political fact resonating off last night's events is how Spain has modernised socially. I watched the match in a bar full of Catalan people, some of whom had been on the million strong demo in favour of independence from Spain the day before, carrying banners saying "Adeu Espana". As they surged onto the street last night they were all for Spain, and they were met by the entire staff of a Pakistani-owned pizza shop called Al Capone's, who surrounded me shouting (in English): "We are Spanish, we are Spanish. We Love Spain!". On the streets where the Catalan flag and language were once repressed, people used both to celebrate the Spanish victory. In a landscape shaped by inquisition-era Catholicism, gay men leapt around in the fountains wearing only bathing trunks bearing the word "Espana".

Basically, as in the Facebook profile option, "it's complicated" - and there is no going back.
But, ah, it ain't so complicated everywhere. Or at least not complicated in the sense of seeing new juxtapositions of attitudes and identities emerging, which manage to be both dichotomies and overlaps. Hyper-modernity carries with it a trailing gown of history's unfinished business in some places.




So we have football fans acting out their (temporary) role as joyful nationalists in one place, and the representatives of two* national traditions acting out their role as anything but joyful football fans in another.

(*No, I've not signed up to the BICO line. But you have to admit that in Northern Ireland it's taking a while for 'all that is solid to melt into air' as Marx put it, and a grudge, held long enough, looks powerfully like a nationalism to me....)

Monday, 17 May 2010

Spare Us the Restoration Comedy, There’s A ‘Live Rail’ Approaching..

At school, I have a hazy memory of the Restoration being presented as being all about the reopening of theatres, unleashing pent up demand for maypoles and the sweeping to Jordan-like fame of buxom orange girls. Wikipedia tells me different:

"In 1661,Oliver Cromwell's body was exhumed from Westminster Abbey, and was subjected to the ritual of a posthumous execution,..... Symbolically, this took place on 30 January; the same date that Charles I had been executed. His body was hanged in chains at Tyburn. Finally, his disinterred body was thrown into a pit, while his severed head was displayed on a pole outside Westminster Hall until 1685."

What brings this to mind? Duh, the amazing discovery that Labour did some things the Tories Don't Like in their last few days in office. Digging up a corpse and giving it a kicking to establish one's own legitimacy has a long pedigree. Hopi needn't over worry about oiling the wheels of a rapid rebuttal unit, this is a very old trick. It will only convince the already converted.

In other news, Gideon and his sidekick Laws have announced a significant move towards taxation without representation in the form of an Office for Budgetary Responsibility. And the Times are leading on the plan to move forwards towards the sunny uplands of political and democratic renewal by ...er, creating 160+ new unelected peers. My, isn't last year's crisis of political legitimacy over MPs expenses paying dividends now for those who need to insulate their next moves from any kind of democratic accountability? My gut feeling is that these moves will prove ephemeral: I agree with Potlatch when he says a fiscal crisis, as we now face, represents a political choice inviting political answers.

Meanwhile, amongst the grownups, Merkel has acknowledged that the Eurozone bailout isn't a permanent fix. George Magnus (that calm, hyper-intelligent guy from UBS with a Keynes-like 'tache that Mason often interviews on Newsnight) agrees. He seems to be saying he does not think the European Union's Greek rescue will be enough to resolve the situation or stop it from spiralling into a structural crisis for all large debtor nations in the industrialised world - unless somehow the EU becomes a fully political union. Indeed, at points, his carefully technical language gets even scarier: he seems to suggest that more or less the entire Western World is moving into a 'debt trap': no plausible growth rates are going to be sufficiently high to offset the rising cost of borrowing for Govts.

I'm no economist but I think this means he's saying we're going to have to pay more tax for less services and it's still not going to be enough to stabilise the situation. If things get really bad, there seem to be two ways out of this currently being kicked about in technical economic discussion:

1. As George Magnus suggests, the Eurozone might have to move to complete political union – the much discussed 'United States of Europe'. I regard this as utterly unfeasible, but things change quickly under this sort of pressure.

2. For the weaker members of the Eurozone to leave and re-establish their own currencies. But no one has the faintest idea of how to do this and if it happened it would be a crushing blow, not only to the political 'project' of the EU but also to trade within the EU, which represents a high proportion of all world trade.

Either eventuality would certainly mean that quite a bit of British held Greek/Portuguese/Spanish and, especially, Irish debt would be 'restructured': the preferred financial euphemism for 'you can whistle for it matey, I'm not paying'.

Europe is famously the 'live rail' of Tory party politics- just think how much more electricity that rail is carrying now they're in coalition with a pro-European Party....

Friday, 7 May 2010

Lopsided Inheritance

The big news yesterday was, of course, the surprise announcement that most modern humans descended from ancient stock that left Africa early on are, in fact, 1%- 4% Neanderthal.*

So species inter-breeding is possible within the wider human family.

But I wouldn't expect to see even 4% of the Lib-Dem programme make the statute books if Clegg gets into bed with Cameron.

& we're still left with the mystery of why exactly the Neanderthals and modern humans couldn't co-exist in Europe....oh, hang on there's another analogy just forming in the back of my brain...


*As anyone who has ever watched an interview with Blackburn Rovers' manager already knew.

Saturday, 16 May 2009

Message to New Labour: What A Social Democratic Platform for the Euro Elections Might Look Like


For [insert name of social democratic party], people always come first. We believe in a Europe which offers everyone the opportunity to travel and work in other countries as long as their rights are protected and respected. We will continue to work to end discrimination and worker exploitation through the adoption of stricter laws and improved workers’ rights throughout Europe. If it’s easier and cheaper for companies to sack workers in [insert name of home country] than in other countries, that’s exactly what will happen. We are committed to stronger European legislation to prevent this.

We supported the European directive on temporary workers’ rights which the Labour government blocked for so long and we are committed to protecting workers rights when companies are taken over – unlike Labour, who voted against this. We have fought hard for the right to proper information and consultation of workers by companies, which could have prevented so many major redundancies. We supported the Working Time Directive which protects people from having to work excessive hours.

In 2009, UK trades union members have fewer rights to take industrial action than in 1906. We will support better protection against the dismissal or victimisation of workers taking part in lawful action; we will also support action to prevent the use of agency workers replacing striking workers.

[insert name of social democratic party] believes in equal working conditions for economic migrants: we are committed to an increase in the minimum wage and improved support, guidance and resources for local authorities working with immigrant communities. At present the Gangmasters Licensing Authority has no real presence in [insert name of home country]: we call for both a widened remit and a permanent [insert name of home country] office to ensure that the exploitation of workers is tackled on the ground.

We believe in a Europe where wages and jobs are protected; a Europe where conditions are equal all over the continent. We believe in a Europe of harmonised working conditions, where employers cannot drive down pay by exploiting cheap labour in another country. To ensure that companies are prevented from Undercutting local pay rates and exploiting workers, we support an urgent revision of the Posted Workers Directive.

We do not believe in a market-run Europe which values profit over people. The current global financial crisis proves that a Europe which promotes privatisation and deregulation is a Europe in which our banking services collapse in a flurry of irresponsible lending, our post offices close and our communities wither. We want a European-wide minimum state guarantee on savings of €150,000. If the banks are going to gamble with our money, there must be safety measures in place to ensure that we, the ordinary savers, do not suffer from their recklessness.

[insert name of social democratic party] also believes that it is high time that the banks give something back to the people for whom they work. To this end, we call for a Europe-wide tax on international banking transactions which would raise billions for meeting global challenges such as international development and climate change. Every time currency is traded across European borders by bankers, this Tobin tax would help to stabilise the volatile money markets, encourage accountability and promote responsibility in the banking sector.

Lightly adapted from here (via). Unfortunately not a voting option in England.


Friday, 24 April 2009

Polanyi Again

The Great Transformation again. This time on the differential effects of pre-existing class structures on the 'birth marks' left on the working class movements in Britain and on Continental Europe:

".....there was no comparison between the moral and cultural catastrophe of the English cottager or copyholder of direct ancestry, who found himself helplessly sinking into the social and physical slums of some Northwestern factory neighbourhood....and the Slovakian or...Pomerian agricultural labour changing overnight from a stable dwelling peon into a industrial worker in a modern metropolis. ...the English yeoman's son or the evicted cottager certainly did not feel his status raised...the recently emancipated farm labourer of the continent [had] a fair chance of rising into the lower middle class...[and] even the bourgeoisie, which socially towered above him, was politically in the same boat, being almost as removed from ranks of the actual ruling class as he was himself...In England the middle classes...were strong enough to vindicate their rights alone, and not even in their near revolutionary effort in 1832 did they look to the labourers for support...while on the Continent the still semi feudal aristocracy did not intermarry with....the bourgeoisie and the absence of..primogeniture hermetically insulated them from the other classes. Every successful step towards equal rights and liberties thus benefited Continental middle and working classes alike...it was part of the Continental tradition that the working class would help fight the battles of the bourgeoisie against feudalism, if only...to be cheated by the middle class of the fruits of victory. But whether the working class won or lost...its experience was enhanced, and its aims raised to a political level...While the British worker developed an incomparable experience in the personal and social problems of unionism and left national politics to 'his betters', the Central European worker became a political socialist, expected to deal with the matters of statecraft, though primarily with those that concerned his own interests....The Continental worker needed protection..against the normal action of factory and labour market conditions. He achieved it mainly by the help of legislation, while his British comrades relied more on voluntary association – trade unions – and their power to monopolise labour. While economically the difference be over rated...politically its consequences were great. On the Continent trade unions were the creation of the political parties of the working class; in England the political party was the creation of the trade unions."

This, I think, is closer to Anderson and Nairn than Thomson's Peculiarities of the English, but I don't want to re-open that debate. I merely quote at such length to ask whether a leftwing party need be based on the trade unions. I don't think it does, I don't even think it is desirable because it muddies certain waters in terms of roles - which is why I fear people like Phil and Stroppy are radically mis-reading the potential and significance of NO2EU, which looks to me like a train-crash about to happen.

Monday, 23 March 2009

I Think too Small Sometimes

Willem Buiter examines why the European Central Bank can't easily do Quantitative Easing, the anti-deflationary move de jour. It's a hugely technical article that I'm not going to pretend I fully understood (Any of my fellow non bankers care to explain a seigniorage Laffer curve without consulting Google? Thought not). But the idea at the heart of it seems simple enough to me: a central bank can only properly function as such if it has the backing of a tax raising state.

In normal times, a lot of effort is put into making this backing as ambiguous as possible to reassure markets that they are free from direct political control - hence the so called independence of the Bank of England. But the BoE is 100% owned by HM Treasury. The ECB is owned by 27 national central banks, each with their own constitution and particular relationship to their home state.

Buiter indicates that the markets are pricing in the possibility of default by some Eurozone national governments - particularly Ireland, Greece, Portugal, Italy and Spain (in that order of risk). So,

".... it is reasonable for the EBC/Eurosystem to insist on a joint and several guarantee by all 16 Eurozone governments for any Eurozone government debt acquired by the ECB...... Such a joint and several guarantee does not exist at the moment - a reflection of the absence of a fiscal Europe and a fiscal Eurozone...The ECB has no fiscal back-up. There is no guarantee, insurance or indemnity for any private credit risk it assumes. "

So it can't easily do Quantitative Easing. Which would seem to suggest either clever folk like Buiter convince them to sort out some 'held-together-with-string' temporary fix (which he doesn't think will work given the Fortis experience), something big has got to change in the democratic architecture of Europe or, simply, deflation beckons across the Eurozone.


Back in December I wrote,

"That hoary old Marxist chestnut of a question, the relative autonomy of the State, may rear its head again. A thousand undergraduate essays ...... will be dusted down and regurgitated. But the old essays may be missing the point. It may be that the thing to explain in 2009 is not the 'gap' between direct class power and State action which Miliband and Poulantzas tried to theorise, but the speed and nature at which this gap decreases."

But I was talking about the UK, not the EU. I think too small sometimes.